judging the cybils graphic novels

Judging the Cybils Graphic Novels Category

There were so many great graphic novels on the short list for the Cybils, particularly in the Young Adult category! The Cybils do not include honorable mentions so my take is just my own opinion and not that of the Graphic Novel judging committee. I wanted to spotlight a few standouts that are worth hunting down.

2013 Cybils

YA Graphic Novel Notables from 2013

Young Adult Graphic Novel winner, Templar by Jordan Mechner and illustrated by husband and wife team LeUyen Pham  and Alex Puvilland and Boxers and Saints by Gene Luen Yang and Lark Pien both tackled epic historical events where the story is told through imagined characters.

Mechner’s fully developed and complex characters of rogue knights in Templar edged out the Chinese rebels and Christian converts in Boxers and Saints for me. The lush illustrations by Pham and Puvillard brought to life the story of how a small band of renegade knight crusaders regained the lost treasure of the Knights Templar during 14th century France. The Templar story has been widely and successfuly told in other genres but Mechner, Pham and Puvilland have created a version that will bring a new teen audience to this captivating period of history.

The YA Graphic Novel category was really strong this year. Notables include War Brothers by Sharon McKay and Daniel Lafrance about the Ugandan child soldiers; Captain Marvel, Vol. 1: In Pursuit of Flight by Kelly Sue Deconnick, Dexter Soy and Emma Rios which finally gives Captain Marvel the spotlight she deserves; and Delilah Dirk and the Turkish Lieutenant by Tony Cliff which portrays a female “Indiana Jones” heroine.


YA Graphic Novel Winner is Templar!

Templar by Jordan Mechner and illustrated by husband and wife team LeUyen Pham  and Alex Puvilland is the winner of the Young Adult Graphic Novel category. Mechner’s take on this popular topic uses imagined characters focusing on a small band of renegade knights and includes an unfinished love story. Lush illustrations by husband and wife team LeUyen Pham and Alex Puvilland work in tandem with Mechner to create fully developed characters, conveying not just 14th century France, but the emotions and distinct personalities of each individual.

This graphic novel is a perfectly paced page turner that alternates with action centered on post-Crusades France as the Templar knights are tried for heresy by the king and the relationships of the band of outlaw knights as they struggle to unpuzzle the whereabouts of the treasure while staying one step ahead of their pursuers. In outwitting the King’s men and his villainous advisor, Nogaret, Mechner’s band captures the hearts and imaginations of the reader as the enormnity of their task is revealed. They are noble pawns in a timeless game of politics, power and money.

The Templar story has been widely and successful told in other genres but Mechner, Pham and Puvilland have created a compelling version that will bring a new younger audience to this captivating period of history.


Judging The Cybils

What was it like to judge the Cybils? Very orderly and organized. First we received the finalists list and tried to read as many as possible from the library. What books we could not find were then sent to us by the publishers. I actually found that it’s better to read the books from the library to get them faster since I knew my deadline to finish them coincided with Multicultural Children’s Book Day.

Next we filled out a spreadsheet ranking the books, one for Middle Grade and another for Young Adult. The winner for the Middle Grade graphic novel was clear from the numbers but it was very close for the YA so we held a very civil discussion via email to decide the winner.

I would definitely recommend applying to be a judge for the Cybils. It’s a fun experience and it forced me to read the best graphic novels published in 2013, a task that I relish but wouldn’t have done otherwise! I might apply for a different category and apply for first round next year. There’s no guarantee that I’ll be selected so I might apply for more than one slot.

Are you thinking about judging the Cybils? C’mon, do it! It’s fun! What are your favorite graphic novels from 2013?


p.s. My favorite Middle Grade graphic novels were:

The Lost Boy by Greg Ruth

I loved this imaginative tale of two worlds coexisting side by side, separated only by a  portal key that is missing. Nate is a new kid in town who discovers this strange world after unearthing a old tape recorder from under the floorboards of his room. He must solve the mystery of a lost boy from long ago in order to defeat a powerful force that threatens his world. To do this, he must get help from Tabitha, a local girl, and reunite a lost boy with his family.

Hereville: How Mirka Met a Meteorite by Barry Deutsch

Deutsch masterfully crafted a story with a unique perspective. How many stories celebrate an Orthodox Jewish family without making religion the central story problem? Mirka’s restless energy, boundless imagination, and flawed, fierce, relatable personality will connect with kids. The characters that share her journey are fleshed out enough that you get a real feel for their personality. The panels and art are engaging and easy to follow, and even the color scheme helps support the narrative. All of these features make Hereville: How Mirka Met a Meteorite a perfect match for middle grade readers. from The Cybils Awards

March Book 1 by John LewisAndrew Aydin and Nate Powell

This is a powerful true story of Civil Rights icon John Lewis. I am looking forward to Book 2! I have this on my Civil Rights Books for Kids list. Thank you to Jenny of Books Babies and Bows for this link to NPR about March:

That story ­spanning the Congressman’s seven decades, will be told in three books. March is the first.

Till was a 14-year-old boy brutally killed in Mississippi for allegedly whistling at a white woman. His murder received national attention and helped galvanize the civil rights movement. In the graphic novel, we see an image of Till’s mangled body. Drawn from above, after Till has been dragged from the river, Powell makes thin jagged lines of ink to create a sense of human flesh that’s turned into broken twigs.

Lewis says, just like the Martin Luther King comic book that inspired him, March is also a primer on non-violence. The Congressman says this is a lesson he and his co-authors, Aydin and Powell, want to keep alive.

“I remember hearing Martin Luther King Jr. preach from time to time,” says Lewis. “And his father would be in the pulpit. And he would say, ‘Son―make it plain―make it plain.’­ So between Nate and Andrew, they made it plain.”

Squish #5: Game On by Jennifer L. Holm, illustrated by Matthew Holm

If kids were to pick a winner, it would be, hand down, Squish #5: Game On. And it’s a good message to gamers about the dangers of too much screen time. A message that my son could bear repeating!

To examine any book more closely at Amazon, please click on image of book.

judging the cybils graphic novels

I am an Amazon affiliate which means if you buy anything through my blog, I get a very small kickback at no cost to you. I use this money to pay for postage and handling for my giveaways.

Follow PragmaticMom’s board Best Graphic Novels on Pinterest.

By Mia Wenjen, PragmaticMom


  1. Great post! I loved reading about your experiences. I’m glad you enjoyed being part of the Cybils. Thank you for your work on the judging team!

    I loved The Lost Boy as well. (Although I guess that’s obvious since I nominated it). I loved how it turned out to be a story of redemption, and had more depth than I expected when I started it. It’s one that takes a little bit to get into at the start (at least it was for me) but it’s definitely worth sticking with it.
    Sheila Ruth recently posted…Book Review: The Summer PrinceMy Profile

    • Hi Sheila,
      The Cybils was my first experience judging books and I’d love to do that again! Thanks so much for all your work on the Cybils. It was extremely well run! I am still rooting for The Lost Boy and hope that middle school age boys will discover it!! It almost felt like it should have been YA instead of Middle Grade … right on the cusp though the YA Graphic Novel category was chock full of strong contenders!
      Pragmatic Mom recently posted…Funny Science-y Math-y Chapter Books for ages 7 and upMy Profile

  2. There is a great NPR story (if you search March and John Lewis you should find it) about the creation of March and the history of a comic book Martin Luther King Jr. and the Montgomery story. The book is fascinating, but very realistic with the brutality of the era, especially the murder of Emmett Till.
    Jenny recently posted…Zen and the Art of Reading- What blogging for a year has taught me.My Profile

  3. REally enjoyed your post and all of your wonderful experiences. Will have to check out some of the graphic novels you judged.

    Finally added your blog as a link on my website, so I can access it a little more easily. We are on two different systems and I was having a hard time knowing when you post. Now I can check periodically.
    Patricia Tilton recently posted…Kwirky: The Kid Detective with a Different PerspectiveMy Profile

  4. Squish sounds interesting! Johnny loves graphic novels.
    maryanne recently posted…Harry Potter Birthday PartyMy Profile

  5. I’m pinning this for near future reference!! This is so useful!!
    Roshni recently posted…Mother and Daughter RelationshipsMy Profile

  6. I know! right? I so wanted the “Honor” Books to be listed .. especially since the winning title and the next few in line were really great reads. On the other hand, they do have a “finalists” list for each category published a few weeks before the finals.
    I am looking forward to reading some of these.. I LOVED Bluffton and was so disappointed that it didn’t make the list. On the other hand, since it didn’t make it, I am curious to read the above reads!! 🙂
    Thanks for joining us this week at KidLit BlogHop Mia!
    -Reshama @ Stackingbooks
    Reshama recently posted…I Am Abraham LincolnMy Profile

    • Hi Reshama,
      I think we share the same passion for promoting great books for kids!! It is hard to focus on just the winner when the honor books are so good too! Here’s a plus for every short list … they are all winners!!!

      Bluffton was a more unusual graphic novel. I can see why it was very popular. The watercolor illustrations were lovely and the book is based on a real life person and such an interesting story. I hope the word gets out about that one too!
      Pragmatic Mom recently posted…Skype Author Visit with Jarrett Krosoczka and GIVEAWAYMy Profile

  7. Great job again. My son (who is now grown with his own small boy) would have loved graphic novels. He enjoyed comics because he\’s always been such a visual learner. Thanks for sharing with us. Cheryl
    Cheryl Carpinello recently posted…Diego’s Dragon Book BlastMy Profile

Leave a Comment

CommentLuv badge