Grace Lin’s Latest Chapter Book Deserves Newbery
I don’t think there was a 4th grade or 5th grade kid I knew who read Where The Mountain Meets the Moon by Grace Lin and didn’t rave about it though they were generally girls. It could be that Minli is a girl. I hope Lin’s audience broadens with her latest companion book, Starry River of the Sky. Rendi, the lead character, is a BOY! And he couldn’t be more different than Minli who is cheerful despite poverty and hardship.
Grace Lin weaves Chinese folk tales into her own adventure of a young boy who rebels against his cruel and uncaring father by running away, ending up in a remote village where the moon never shines. There is something strange about the people who live here too, including a mysterious moaning cry that only Rendi seems able to hear.
In this second tale, Lin’s characters seem more realistic compared to Minli’s unflagging good cheer in Where The Mountain Meets the Moon. True, there are also mystical creatures in Starry River of the Sky but they are more veiled. It’s this magical realism, with emphasis on realism, that I hope will attract boys to her latest book.
In both books, her beautiful and intricate illustrations help to subtly tell the tale and she uses Chinese cut paper art as a reference point as well as borders that mimic intricate Chinese brocade weavings. Both these art references are appropriate. Paper puppets were used traditionally to tell stories as entertainment and would include mythology stories. In a way, Lin’s books are a modern version of itinerant Chinese puppet storytellers.
And weaving is what Lin does best in melding centuries upon centuries of Chinese mythology into a modern yet timeless story that still speaks to human characteristics of greed, love, and rebellion.
I think that Starry River of the Sky is the stronger of her much-lauded two books, though Where the Mountain Meets the Moon deserved Newbery accolades. The only thing that prevents her second from winning Newbery gold is the similarity of the stories. Where the Mountain Meets the Moon was such a revelation of “modern” Chinese Mythology retelling that Starry River of the Sky will seem like an old idea. I hope the judges will view it as a separate entity. As a standalone book, it is as good, if not better!
I was lucky to get a short interview with her:
1) Was it deliberate that Rendi seems to be the polar opposite of Minli both in temperament and social standing?
Ha, it’s funny you say that because Minli was based a bit on me, and Rendi was based a bit on my husband! But Rendi is the first boy protagonist that I have written, I wasn’t trying to make him the polar opposite of Minli but I did want to make sure he was distinctly different.
2) Mountains and moons figure into both Where the Mountain Meets the Moon and The Starry River of the Sky. Was there a particular Chinese mythology tale that prompted this as the anchor for both books or was there several stories that collided into your books? Alternately, was there something personal about those stories that spoke to you?
Well, my favorite Chinese holiday is the Moon Festival and there are so many Chinese stories and legends that revolve around the moon. It wasn’t really a specific tale that inspired me, but rather the whole genre! It seemed natural, to me, to find a way to make all the stories connect even though they did not originally.
3) What made you embrace your “Asian-ness” post-childhood?
After high school, I went to the art school—the Rhode Island School of Design and they had a special program where you could study in Rome, Italy for a year. I participated in the program and went to Italy.
It was there that I suddenly realized how little I knew about my own heritage. Italians were so proud of their history and culture, and while I am American I couldn’t claim the pioneers of the West in my ancestry. But the ancestry I could claim, my “Asian-ness” I knew absolutely nothing about. And that made me feel sad and suddenly I yearned to know more.
4) I am hoping there will be more companion books … please?! Is there another book in the works?
There should be one more, I hope! In my head I wanted to have three, each book representing an element : sky (“Where the Mountain Meets the Moon”), earth (“Starry River of the Sky”) and water (the book to come!). I have inklings of ideas for it but they are still percolating…and it might not be about water even though I want it to be. Stories have a way of being obstinately about what they want to be About.
To examine any of the items listed, please click on image of item. As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.
I received a review copy of Starry River of the Sky in order to participate in the blog tour. I believe it was my enthusiasm for Grace Lin’s work that landed me a spot. My opinions are my own but honestly, I am a huge fan of Grace Lin’s books!
Follow PragmaticMom’s board Multicultural Books for Kids on Pinterest.
Follow PragmaticMom’s board Children’s Book Activities on Pinterest.
My books:
Amazon / Signed or Inscribed by Me
Amazon / Signed or Inscribed by Me
Food for the Future: Sustainable Farms Around the World
- Junior Library Guild Gold selection
- Massachusetts Book Award Long List
- Selected as one of 100 Outstanding Picture Books of 2023 by dPICTUS and featured at the Bologna Children’s Book Fair
- Starred review from School Library Journal
- Chicago Library’s Best of the Best
- 2023 INDIES Book of the Year Awards Finalist
- Green Earth Book Award Long List
- Imagination Soup’s 35 Best Nonfiction Books of 2023 for Kids
Amazon / Barefoot Books / Signed or Inscribed by Me
Amazon / Scholastic / Signed or Inscribed by Me
Thanks Mia for the heads up about the new book and the review. We all loved “Where the Mountain Meets the Moon” (ages 5 and 7 and grown ups at the time). I even read part of it to my daughter’s 2nd grade class and many of them immediately signed up to check it out of their class library. I think we’ll have to flip for who gets to read it first, or, better yet, maybe we’ll read it together. But that will probably lead to later bed times – “Just one more chapter…!” Big Grace Lin fans over here too. If she does any readings in the Boston area please blog alert us!
Hi Kimberly,
I just checked Grace Lin’s website to see if she lists her book signing appearances but did not see any. She DOES do 10 minute Q and A Skype visits to kids’ book clubs who have read her books: http://www.gracelin.com/content.php?page=skype
I’ll keep you posted if I find out more about her Boston readings. She was at Boston Public Library Tea for Kids’ fundraiser for Literacy Lights. I think that already happened and it sold out quickly. I bet she might do something with Brookline Booksmith or Newtonville books!
I’ve been following all week, and enjoyed hearing more about this new book by Grace Lin. I’ve used the moon in a variety of ways with my students, in science and in writing, so was happy to hear a little more about the moon in Chinese folktales. Thanks!
Hi Linda,
Thank you so much!! What a great idea to incorporate chapter books into your moon study! I think your students will enjoy this book!
I completely agree with your review of this book. I thought it was not possible to love a book more than Mountain/Moon. I saw Grace Lin speak last Friday and she was so gracious and funny.
Yay for Grace Lin! She is so talented!!! Fantastic review too!!!
Hi Ann,
Love Grace Lin too! Thanks so much!
Aww, thanks so much for your nice words–I wish you were on the Newbery Committee! I’m delighted you enjoyed the book so much and it was lovely to be interviewed by you!
Hi Grace,
Thanks so much for stopping by. The Newbery committee is out of my league but I will apply to be on the Cybils committee next year! I tried to nominate you for Cybills but someone beat me to it! 🙂
I’m intrigued by Starry River. Do you think Damian, being 4, is too young to understand? Cause I really do want to read this book. 😀 oh to heck with it, I’m going to buy it anyway.
Hi Vanita,
I think it might be a little confusing for a 4-year-old. I think he’d really enjoy it in 4th or 5th grade if he reads it to himself and maybe 2nd or 4rd grade if someone read it to him. Let me try it out as a read aloud to my 7-year-old. I’m not sure if it will hold my son’s attention right now.